By
Eric Staples
October 29, 2009
Even Zen philosophy isn’t beyond the Center for Pain Relief’s methodology for treating pain.
Photo by Patrick Riley.
Head nurse Janie Shively discuses some of the advanced machines and techniques used to diagnose and treat a range of problems caused by pain.
Photo by Patrick Riley.
Alex Cahana, M.D., (left) and David Tauben, M.D., (right) Discuss an e-mail they had just received, concerning a patient's pain levels at the Center for Pain Relief.
“We say in English ‘I have pain,’” said Dr. Alex Cahana, medical director for the UW Center for Pain Relief. “In Zen, they say it differently because it’s not something you own. They say, ‘there is pain.’”
A new center opened earlier this month that can perhaps revolutionize the way doctors look at pain, and it’s quickly making its way into the UW’s medical school curriculum. Students are being exposed to new methods of treating pain and are seeing how impactful the results are.
“[Patients] come [to the center] with the expectation of eliminating their pain, and they leave with the expectation of living with their pain,” said Amanda Braaten, a medical student studying anesthesiology. “It’s getting people to think differently.”
Dr. David Tauben, who specializes in internal medicine and pain management, shared his insights on how pain is treated.
“My vision is pain and suffering are packaged together, and we pull it apart,” Tauben said. “This is your pain; this is your suffering. Pain is not optional, suffering may be.”
Tauben brought out a record of a recent patient who documented pain levels prior to coming in for treatment and after coming out of treatment at the center. While the patient’s pain level hadn’t changed, the patient commented on how better her life had become, despite the pain.
But changing how patients view pain is only part of the center’s practice.
Cahana spoke of a carpenter who had lost his hand and who came to him with phantom pain, or pain associated with the loss of a limb. The carpenter said he felt the nail of a finger piercing the palm of a hand that didn’t exist.
“We built a special box with a mirror, so when the patient stuck one hand in and the stump in the other, it looks like he has a hand there,” Cahana said. “I said, ‘Look at the mirror and just open the hand.’ … We do that for a couple hours, and he’s able to pull the fingernail out. We’re tricking the brain.”
Traditional methods of treatment, Cahana said, are often the wrong approach to pain. Cahana went on to say that ironically, pain is often mistreated by the use of traditional painkillers like Oxycodone and Oxycontin.
“The normal painkillers are the wrong medication, that is what’s so weird,” Cahana said. “They’re designed for acute pain, they’re not designed for chronic pain. Like, I’ve given people anti-epileptic drugs because epilepsy is a nerve disease, and pain comes from nerves.”
To get more students involved in pain education, Tauben is spearheading a committee that’s developing a new model curriculum for medical-student education, which will involve more students gaining experience in the pain center. There is only room for two students per four-week rotation.
“In medical school, we’re not really taught about chronic pain; it’s pain from more of an acute angle,” Braaten said. “So the center for pain relief is sort of unique because it looks at patients differently than how we’ve been taught to look at them in terms of pain.”
Part of the education component of the center is outreach to practicing doctors who weren’t educated on pain.
“Because of the absence of training in medical school and the slipshod, accidental education of pain as residents, doctors are not well educated in how to take care of pain,” Tauben said.
Because doctors are likely to encounter patients with chronic pain, Braaten agreed that chronic-pain education should be a more prominent part of the curriculum.
“I think that in every area of medicine, there are people with chronic pain,” she said. “So many referrals that the pain center gets are from primary providers who don’t really know what to do with their patients.”
Reach News Editor Eric Staples at news@dailyuw.com.
5 Comments
#1 Lisa Stuebing
on October 29, 2009 at 12:13 p.m.(Location Unknown | Unverified Name | UW Community)
Thanks for the beautiful write-up.
These are exciting times in pain management. There is a central shift in what our providers can do for people. What is even better, is the move away from dangerous and additive drugs.
I am proud to be a part of this team.
Lisa Stuebing
ISO 9000 Project Manager
Division of Pain Medicine
#2 Karla Rixon
on October 29, 2009 at 3:15 p.m.(Seattle, WA | Unverified Name)
As a UW student and patient with chronic pain who has been treated at programs similar to what the UW Center for Pain Relief is offering, I have to say that this article appears to be extremely one sided. The shift away from actually trying to treat pain, a shift toward offering lifestyle and philosophical advice, may seem great from the perspective of medical providers. It allows doctors who would otherwise be helpless to feel like they're offering some benefit, which I'm sure is great for their self-esteem. However, this approach can be extremely condescending toward a patient's own experience of pain, and in my experience often verges on victim blaming as doctors attribute any lack of improvement to a patient's own mindset instead of examining the effectiveness of the treatment they provide.
While I agree that many doctors are completely uneducated about chronic pain, and it is encouraging that the issue of pain is being treated as something worth serious study, I worry that the adoption of Zen as the preferred treatment option will keep doctors from looking at real solutions for chronic pain patients, solutions that could actually reduce the pain patients experience instead of offering minimal coping strategies to help patients resign themselves to an incurable condition, which is what the treatment described in this article amounts to in my experience. Perhaps The Daily can do an article on the hard scientific research into the neurological causes of chronic pain that is being done at the UW Medical Center- assuming there is any.
#3 CPR RN
on November 4, 2009 at 9:47 a.m.(UW Campus | Unverified Name | UW Community)
In response to Karla, we really do appreciate your feed back. The purpose of the article was to help people think in different terms regarding pain. However, these are not all of the treatment options offered at the Center for Pain Relief. We provide procedural interventions, rehabilitation, counselling and trial medications. We are also involved in various research projects. We have providers that our world renouned in their field and doing cutting edge treatments not offered else where. Our goal for the article was to help people understand that a "pill" is the solution and that we approach pain from every angle. We are trying to change Americans' cultural interpretation of pain.
#4 CPR RN
on November 4, 2009 at 9:50 a.m.(UW Campus | Unverified Name | UW Community)
*renowned.
*a pill is NOT the solution
#5 solitice
on January 10, 2010 at 2:12 a.m.(Seattle, WA | Unverified Name)
Are you interested in physical pain? I don’t think you are not qualified to talk about pain eric!
Post a comment