By
Elizabeth Brady
April 29, 2008
Who doesn’t love breast milk? After all, it’s recommended by the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) that mothers breast-feed exclusively for the first year of their child’s life. Studies show that breast milk can guard infants against diarrhea, ear infections, Sudden Infant Death Syndrome, diabetes, obesity and asthma, as well as prevent illness throughout childhood.
Despite this rave review — which my son greedily seconds — my experience at the UW has been that perhaps not everybody loves breast-feeding after all.
Last September, I began my graduate program as a temporarily single mom while my husband was working overseas. As a result, any extracurricular activities I attended always involved me plus one. The one was a 6-month-old boy who loved attention and moo juice — and had no hang-ups about who was nearby when the dinner bell rang.
My son came to picnics and meetings, and, in a pinch, the occasional rescheduled class. He also came to happy hour. In a world where my home life consisted of no grown-up companionship, or even a TV to bask in the glow of, the fact that my school had a bi-monthly happy hour was a welcome opportunity to meet my peers, find out what classes to take and eat food that wasn’t prepackaged at Trader Joe’s. The organizers were nice enough to select locations that were family-friendly, and had highchairs and an all-ages policy. This of course didn’t change the fact that I had a baby in a bar.
The United States is comparatively prudish when it comes to nursing in public; in many countries (including most of Europe), it’s a fairly normal phenomenon.
When I fed my son at the table, he operated for the most part below the radar, except for the occasional loud burp or smacking sound. Some people were quite surprised when I switched sides that there was a baby there at all. When they did realize that there was a woman at their very table exposing herself (under a blanket), and using her curves for something other than getting to the front of the line at a club. The expressions I saw were ones of surprise and discomfort. It was similar to a wedding in which the best man calls the bride a whore and then vomits all over his tuxedo during the toast. No one knew where to look, or if it was appropriate to laugh. Once the surprise wore off, people handled the situation in one of three ways.
The first way was very La Leche League-friendly. People complimented me on choosing to nurse, and continued our conversation as if nothing strange was occurring. For those of you who don’t know, this is the correct behavior.
The second way was a mix of revulsion and intense curiosity. This happened anywhere I breastfed. There was always at least one person who couldn’t look away, as if the bundle under my shawl was a terrible car crash. Sometimes there was a creepy jealous element to this curiosity. While this probably would have been a normal response for a 2-year-old, when the person was a fascinated man of driver’s license age or above, I became a bit uncomfortable. Questions ensued in voices that grew less and less ironic: “What does breast milk taste like?” “Can I have some?” “What would it do if I put it in my coffee?” This next question was my favorite: “Were there super powers to breast milk that the AAP did not advertise on its Web site?”
I can imagine their slogan: “Breast milk causes increase in LSAT scores” or “New cure for hangover: Mix two parts human milk with one part Pepto Bismol.” When I pumped at school, I stored milk in a communal fridge. I wonder, to this day, if anybody ever used some for their coffee, accidentally or on purpose.
The third reaction was simply undiluted revulsion. One friend suggested that I feed my son in a toilet stall. Good plan: teach my son to read in a graffiti-soaked stall as I spend 20 minutes trying not to touch the walls while feeding him.
Just because people have invented iPods does not make us any less a part of the mammal family. Our young need milk, and it (unlike cosmetic surgery or hair extensions) is a natural and healthy phenomenon.
Another friend, Ben, grew up on a dairy farm in Idaho, and his criticisms were more economic in nature. At 6-foot-something and probably the recipient of near-perfect GRE scores, Ben is a proud product of formula feeding (proving that those who don’t breast-feed can also have lovely children). He wanted to know why I would take jobs away from hardworking Midwestern cows in this time of economic downturn.
What can I say? Outsourcing is a bitch.
6 Comments
#1 Miriam Labbok, MD, MPH
on April 29, 2008 at 8:51 a.m.(Chapel Hill, NC | Unverified Name)
Dear Eliz.:
I would love to share your experience with grad students everywhere. Here, at the UNC School of Public Health, where you would expect full support for breastfeeding, few women dare. There are those who support formula as an equally appropriate approach to infant nutrition. We have mother's room for milk expression, not as yet fully supported by the administration, but we all know that expressed milk, while better than any other infant food, is a poor second to the many benefits of breastfeeding for child health and development.
Thanks for writing this, and please stay in touch - together, we may just change the world!!
Best wishes,
Miriam
Professor and Director
Center for infant and young child feeding and care
Department of Maternal and Child Health
UNC School of Public Health
www.sph.unc.edu/mch/ciycfc
#2 Stephanie
on April 29, 2008 at 10:05 a.m.(Bellevue, WA | Unverified Name)
As a friend of Elizabeth's I have listened with quiet horror and indignation to the stories of what she has endured at the UW during her attempts to balance a masters program and raising a child.
I am glad to see this article written so that the wider UW community can think about ways to improve circumstances for parents like Elizabeth. Better policies to assist breast-feeding students as well as staff - plus more support and understanding from the community - are needed.
It takes a special kind of strength to pursue higher education while doing a commendable job raising a child. Elizabeth exemplifies a shining example of what society claims to value - a strong, driven woman who is also a wonderful mother. We should support her and people like her.
#3 Max
on April 29, 2008 at 10:40 a.m.(UW Campus | Unverified Name)
I feel i was the one who suggested you feed your baby in a toilet stall. I thought he should get to know the ins and outs of communal toilets, from no toilet paper to glory holes. Perhaps, upon reflection, he was too young. Sorry.
#4 Laurie
on April 29, 2008 at 4:52 p.m.(Reston, VA | Unverified Name)
Bravo Elizabeth for breastfeeding your son! Breastfeeding is a wonderful way to bond with your child and I know for a fact (being Elizabeth's mom) that breastfed babies turn out to be fantasic, well-adjusted adults. If public breastfeeding makes some people uncomfortable, they should get over it. It is natural, economical, and the best nutrition for babies.
#5 Meghan
on May 2, 2008 at 4:39 a.m.(Seattle, WA | Unverified Name)
Eighteen months into my second breastfeeding relationship and one year into my graduate program, I've often been the one with a baby in a bar. There's nothing like breastfeeding a squirmy toddler who won't stay under a blanket, even if I were interested in using one, and trying to have a conversation with someone whose eyes won't meet yours. But every day I'm glad I nurse my daughter, just as I was glad I nursed my son until we were finished. I mean really -- they're just breasts. You can look, guys, I promise -- you won't go blind or anything. Just be forewarned -- you can get a squirt in the eye from across the room if you're not careful.
#6 Vicki
on May 4, 2008 at 1:30 p.m.(UW Campus | Unverified Name)
What a delightful contribution to breast-feeding moms in any setting. I am pleased that you have kept your sense of humor while shedding light on the reality of human bias. Yes breasts are most often the subject of sex and/or beauty, but their real purpose is nourishment for offspring. Hats off to you
Post a comment