By
Jackson Rohrbaugh
November 30, 2007
Studying abroad is risky. You're placed thousands of miles away from home, in a culture that's foreign and obscure. You often have to learn the language before you can do basic errands and get from place to place easily.
People try to steal from you and take advantage of your naïvety just about everywhere you go. It's difficult to know who you can trust. The situation that's unfolded in Perugia these past few weeks is a scary reminder of how dangerous being in another country can be.
After I lived in Perugia for 10 months, it's hard to say there were no indications that something like this was bound to happen.
Because of the vast student population, and the fact that drinking and merrymaking are allowed outdoors at all hours of the day and night, there is ample opportunity for drug dealers to sell their "wares."
Many dealers are illegal immigrants from North African and Near Eastern countries who come not to seek opportunity and security, but easy money and sensory delights.
While I was there, two of my friends were robbed at knifepoint, and a rival gang a block away from my house gunned down a drug dealer. It's not the safest of places by a long shot.
Perugia is an escapist's pleasure island, where anything goes. The bars stay open until 2 or 3 a.m., and some clubs don't close until the wee hours of the morning. At five in the morning, the square in the center of town is littered with empty cups and finished joints.
Needles bob in storm drains filled with urine. It's not a pretty picture, especially when contrasted with Perugia's beautiful ancient towers and medieval masonry.
It's not all bad, and that's where the conflict is. Even when things like a brutal murder happen, it won't stop students from moving to Perugia to learn the language and lead a different life for a while.
The tragedy surrounding Amanda Knox will force people to be more careful.
It's unfortunate this happened in a city with an atmosphere that facilitated quick friendships and trust between strangers. But in a country like Italy that is so flippant about its laws on drug use and bad behavior in public, this is a warning sign that they haven't been doing enough to protect the people who are within their borders for honest reasons.
One way they could decisively crack down would be to round up dealers who have illegally immigrated and deport them. If you come to a foreign country simply to break the law, perhaps you should try doing it in your homeland first.
You might think that protecting and helping foreigners is of utmost concern to Italian police, but you'd be mistaken. They are notorious for their lackadaisical attitude. I once tried to get help from the police when I was lost in Rome.
When I went to the police station, they opened the steel door to their parking lot, and there before me was a circle of roughly 20 officers who were supposed to be out on patrol. They were smoking, passing a soccer ball between them and joking raucously.
They then pointed me in the opposite of the direction I wanted to go, laughing the whole time.I wandered the dirty, dangerous streets for another two hours until midnight, searching until I found the hostel on my own.
I don't mean to say that they are aiding murder with their laziness, but they also don't do everything possible to ensure their cities are safe places. I hope this incident will inspire authorities to protect students studying abroad.
It's a wakeup call for students to be more careful, but studying abroad should not be discouraged. It is one of the best experiences I've ever had, and Perugia is one of the most amazing, engaging places in the world.
I would advise future travelers to not be foolish. Stay away from drugs while abroad, especially if you don't know where or whom they're from. Don't drink to the point of incoherence. You're a guest in another country, so represent your origins with dignity. Instead of looking for an extended party vacation, see what you can learn.
There will never be a deficit of reasons to go abroad. We long to see other cultures, speak other languages and eat other foods. We must fulfill the desire to leave our doorframe for new horizons.
Equip yourself with common sense, and surround yourself with trustworthy people. The world may be a scary place sometimes, but that's no reason to keep from traveling. We grieve with Meredith Kercher's family, and hope that Perugia, in its unique brand of beautiful disorder, is never tainted by such a terrible act again.
[Reach columnist Jackson Rohrbaugh at opinion@thedaily.washington.edu.]
13 Comments
#1 Will
on November 30, 2007 at 4:56 a.m.(Richmond, VA | Unverified Name)
On the other hand, in a country which isn't flippant about its laws on drugs use and locks up for long terms 20% of all black men because of it--cities like Philly have 300 murders a year, I don't think you can pin this one on bella Italia. The only warning I see is stay far, far away from crazy American girls.
#2 Tim Finnegan
on November 30, 2007 at 10:07 a.m.(Liverpool, United Kingdom | Unverified Name)
Um, are you sure you've got this right? US crime rates are lower than the rest of the world? It's dangerous to go to Italy because you're more likely to get murdered than if you'd stayed in the US?
#3 Tina
on November 30, 2007 at 12:41 p.m.(Seattle, WA | Unverified Name)
I have to disagree with your take on Perugia. Perugia is NOT a party town! I lived there for a lot of last year and did not experience anything you mentioned.
If you had made Italian friends (outside of school and no, not at bars or parties) you would have gotten a glimpse of the real Perugia, not the "study-abroad" Perugia which doesn't teach anything about Umbria.
I have a "hobby" which is dancing Tango. Because of this interest, when I arrived in Italy I sought out tango events in perugia and made my friends that way. This connected me with classy, intelligent people from various age groups and enabled me to form mature friendships.
This speaks for any other hobby. Do you like to write? Join a writers group. Do you like to play soccer? There are soccer clubs there. Do you like Pilates? Perugia has that too. Do you like to sing? Perugia has choirs, both religious and non-religious.
In other words, learn the language, get a hobby and meet people through that.
Stay away from the party scene.
I was so disturbed by how many students I met there who came away from their Perugia experience knowing NOTHING about Perugia's people, history, or local cuisine (ever tasted sagrantino? been to a frantoio? eaten torta al testo? Do you know what umbricelli or stringozzi are?)
And this isn't the fault of the students necessarily - I understand that it's not easy to get out there (especially in a new country) and really learn a place. It's hard to meet locals so you turn to each other (which mixes you with the "wrong" locals)...
Get hobby, join a club, ditch the parties. it's a matter of choice.
#4 Tina
on November 30, 2007 at 12:41 p.m.(Seattle, WA | Unverified Name)
I have to disagree with your take on Perugia. Perugia is NOT a party town! I lived there for a lot of last year and did not experience anything you mentioned.
If you had made Italian friends (outside of school and no, not at bars or parties) you would have gotten a glimpse of the real Perugia, not the "study-abroad" Perugia which doesn't teach anything about Umbria.
I have a "hobby" which is dancing Tango. Because of this interest, when I arrived in Italy I sought out tango events in perugia and made my friends that way. This connected me with classy, intelligent people from various age groups and enabled me to form mature friendships.
This speaks for any other hobby. Do you like to write? Join a writers group. Do you like to play soccer? There are soccer clubs there. Do you like Pilates? Perugia has that too. Do you like to sing? Perugia has choirs, both religious and non-religious.
In other words, learn the language, get a hobby and meet people through that.
Stay away from the party scene.
I was so disturbed by how many students I met there who came away from their Perugia experience knowing NOTHING about Perugia's people, history, or local cuisine (ever tasted sagrantino? been to a frantoio? eaten torta al testo? Do you know what umbricelli or stringozzi are?)
And this isn't the fault of the students necessarily - I understand that it's not easy to get out there (especially in a new country) and really learn a place. It's hard to meet locals so you turn to each other (which mixes you with the "wrong" locals)...
Get hobby, join a club, ditch the parties. it's a matter of choice.
#5 xyz
on November 30, 2007 at 3:14 p.m.(Badalona, Spain | Unverified Name)
So an american girls goes to Italy and murders someone, and it's Italy's fault (a country with much lower crime rate and drug use than the US by the way). Amazing. I wonder what you people learn at WU.
#6 xyz
on November 30, 2007 at 3:17 p.m.(Badalona, Spain | Unverified Name)
Seventh United Nations Survey of Crime Trends and Operations of
Criminal Justice Systems, covering the period 1998 - 2000
(United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, Centre for International
Crime Prevention)
Murders per capita:
#24 United States: 0.042802 per 1,000 people
#47 Italy: 0.0128393 per 1,000 people
Rapes:
#9 United States: 0.301318 per 1,000 people
#46 Italy: 0.0402045 per 1,000 people
http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri...
#7 sydney
on November 30, 2007 at 8:35 p.m.(Ryde, Australia | Unverified Name)
The logic of the artcle is appalling - studying abroad is risky because it would help bringing out the criminal side in someone? And that's not coming from any random blogger but a columnist at WU!
And the comment about deporting illegal immigrants from "north Africa and near East" to stop the drug problem - ever heard of supply and demand? Even if you lock up the entire Africa and Near East there will still be drug dealers, as long as the demand for drugs prevails.
However the article is not entirely useless, the author's perception of Perugia does demonstrate the fact that we all create our own experience and reality, wherever we may be.
#8 Philip
on December 1, 2007 at 2:22 a.m.(Leiden, Netherlands | Unverified Name)
I agree in whole with Sydney (below). The only value in ths otherwise awful article is that it shows how individual ignorance (in this case, the author's) shapes, in a restrictive way, your experiences - if you let it.
I graduated from UW in 1996 - and wouldn't go near The Daily but for the Kercher case. It is clear that the Daily hasn't changed a bit - it is still pathetic in so many ways. My highschool paper was better done. What a shame, as this case could have given a legitimate aspiring journaist a fantastic opportunity.
#9 statguy
on December 1, 2007 at 9:24 a.m.(Badalona, Spain | Unverified Name)
Number of murders per year.
Seattle (population 582,174):
45 (1999), 35 (2000), 25 (2001), 26 (2002), 32 (2003);
Umbria (population 867,878, capital Perugia):
14 (1999), 8 (2000), 16 (2001), 14 (2002), 10 (2003).
Sources:
http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/2...
http://www.andromedalombardia.org/Oss...
#10 statguy
on December 1, 2007 at 9:24 a.m.(Badalona, Spain | Unverified Name)
Number of murders per year.
Seattle (population 582,174):
45 (1999), 35 (2000), 25 (2001), 26 (2002), 32 (2003);
Umbria (population 867,878, capital Perugia):
14 (1999), 8 (2000), 16 (2001), 14 (2002), 10 (2003).
Sources:
http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/2...
http://www.andromedalombardia.org/Oss...
#11 unstatguy
on January 3, 2008 at 7:16 p.m.(Chiaravalle, Italy | Unverified Name)
Hi statguy,
in despite of 867.868 inhabitants, you can't compare Seattle (a city) with the entire Umbria... Umbria is a country ("the green heart of Italy") where most of population lives in small towns and villages.
Perugia's population is about 150.000, only the 17% of the whole umbria's one.. and XX% of the umbria-murders takes place there. If you don't know how much is XX (20? 80?), you can't say anything.
#12 eazybreazy
on January 23, 2008 at 4:50 p.m.(Monticello, MN | Unverified Name)
Its a sad picture you have painted of Perugia, one that I have yet to see in my 3 years of living there. I have never felt unsafe or uneasy about traveling streets late at night. I only know of the embarassment I feel when I go out at night, only to see the girls from the Umbra institute Whoring it up with anything foreign they can get their hands on. Dancing on bars, Stumbling left and right, as some random guy helps them home for an evening of "love" Its sad that they treat such a once in a lifetime blessing, like a semester long spring break in mexico. We wonder why the world looks at us in disgust?....well look at our fine embassadors!
As for the writer of this article, you sound like a f*cking dork, I don't know why I am even replying to this lame ass article?
#13 Rebecca
on November 18, 2008 at 7:22 p.m.(Hackensack, NJ | Unverified Name)
I understand your overall point of being safe when abroad- but I think you were too harsh with focusing this article on Perugia being a party city and a dangerous one at that. Yes it is dangerous, but it is a city. Can't we say that about most cities? I myself faced a very scarey situation with my boyfriend at the time at one of the clubs there where the bouncers started punching him and held me down. This, however doesn't taint my views on the city being anymore dangerous than another.
You mention how the streets are littered with cups, etc- yes they are, but you fail to mention how the next moring it's spotless. I'd like to see NYC figure out how to accomplish that one.
Perhaps you should think a bit about the message you're trying to give before posting such an article...
Post a comment