By
Celeste Gracey
October 11, 2007
I graduated from a fundamentalist Christian high school that saw Harry Potter as the biggest threat to a child’s healthy upbringing since the invention of birth control.
More coverage of...
Christians
Picking up Harry Potter for the first time gave me a feeling I think a pre-teen might have drinking their father’s beer with a friend behind the backyard fence.
I was betraying my cultural upbringing, but the act did not result in the rejection of my faith. Instead, I found that I identified with many of the book’s values and think most people, especially Christians, should too.
So, hold the torch angry parents and teachers alike, and let’s work out why Harry Potter might be more valuable than bonfire material. Because no college student should have to spend the summer after their junior year trying to get to book six, so they can watch the movie in theaters.
(Just a warning, I am going to tell the ending to the Harry Potter series.)
Christian philosopher Arthur Holmes had this neat phrase:
“All truth is God’s truth.”
It explains why some Christians fight evolution so fiercely, instead of just agreeing to disagree. For many it’s a seed of doubt, and it scares them.
I have to write it again: All truth is God’s truth.
So, when authors like J.K. Rowling tell the story about how this really humble and loving person has to die to destroy the ultimate evil, and then he raises from the dead, I jump from my seat and praise God.
The seventh book read more like the Bible story of Jesus than Satan worship. (Jesus, this really humble and loving god-man, died to defeat Satan’s stronghold on the world by overcoming death and raising from the dead.)
I’m not calling Harry Potter Jesus, or saying it was Rowling’s intention to make Potter like Jesus, but I find it ironic that a writer that is so despised by ultra-conservative Christians actually agrees with them in such a profound way.
So what’s the deal with Christians burning piles of these books?
Cultural changes frighten fundamentalist Christians for two reasons. The first is that many American Christians, like all Americans, have a feeling of entitlement when things don’t go their way.
It’s not that I necessarily oppose their political action; American laws give the right to everyone to fight for what they believe is right. But then they do silly things like burn Harry Potter and preach hellfire and brimstone on popular street corners.
There isn’t any real explanation of this, other than it doesn’t look much like Jesus.
Second, Christianity as a whole is one of the most culturally flexible religions out there. The average Christian isn’t a fat, white preacher in a Mercedes, it’s an African living in a dirt-floor hut.
So when Christians aren’t at the forefront of change, they’re hit in the face with how much they’ve failed to embrace their communities.
Instead of deciding to love their community and work on changing the hearts and minds of individual people, like Jesus did back in the day, they scramble to change their community through laws, petitions and crazy protests.
Needless to say, it backfires on the driving point of the Christian faith, which is love God and love people. It angers the Christians who authentically love people, despite if they read Harry Potter, Playboy or the Anarchist’s Cookbook.
Not all Christians opposed Harry Potter, just like not all Christians are politically active or remotely conservative. I know a couple pastors who’ve read the series a couple times and eagerly wait in line for movie tickets.
The best Bible study I’ve gone to had a couple six packs and a bottle of Riesling.
So why pick on witches?
Most Christians believe witches exist, not the Monty-Python, European, burn-‘em-at-the stake kind of witches but the witches that sacrifice small animals in dark places covered in graffiti.
The media often covers witch groups as either silly or friendly. I am sure there are witch groups that are just as they portray, but I’ve heard from several counselors and therapists that those trying to get out of witchcraft often show distinctive problems.
“I see quite a bit of people involved in a cult community or activity, they seem to struggle with higher rates of depression and those kinds of activities (i.e. cutting and suicidal tendencies),” said Cyndie Bohnett, a Redmond therapist who works with abuse cases.
Cults are so community oriented, people trying to get out of them find it increasingly difficult because it requires a total life change, which often compounds existing issues, she added.
Several churches are reminded of witchcraft cults when random curses, like a twisted nail pounded through a Bible, find their way on church doorsteps.
Regardless of whether or not you believe in the authenticity of witchcraft, it’s not all that counter-cultural to not want your children to dabble in something with that track record.
Still, Harry Potter isn’t any more capable of making witches than C.S. Lewis’s Narnia, and Lewis was a Christian writer.
So, as a Christian, I apologize for assuming a sense of entitlement, instead of gratitude and being judgmental, instead of loving. I guess that’s why I’m among many Christians who would consider themselves Harry Potter converts.
[Reach columnist Celeste Flint at opinion@thedaily.washington.edu.]
11 Comments
#1 murgatroid
on October 11, 2007 at 4:16 a.m.(Sydney, Australia | Unverified Name)
You have hit the nail right on the head, and everything you have said I completely agree with 100%
I've been brought up as a good little Catholic girl, regularly going to church, praying, loving my neighbour, but I started reading the books before all the hype of opposition towards the book.
I was 11 years old and I read a book about another kid my age who found himself in the deep end of a world he knew nothing about. And as the following books came out, I grew older and Harry grew older with me.
I was 13 and I understood that Harry Potter was a series about the triumph of good over evil, as well as being an excellent story with funny characters.
It was around this time, after the massive release of Goblet of Fire, and the movie coming out soon that I began to hear stories about book burnings and Anti-Potter, and this I did not understand.
I was 13, and I knew that the books wern't about witchcraft. That was just the background. A plot device, if you will. Thats not what anyone I knew read the books for.
I didn't understand why these grown-ups had no idea why they were being told to hate Harry. That they just accepted it.
I grew older and so did Harry. I read the fifth and sixth books and discovered another major theme - Love. Jesus' great message. And then I heard about a lady who was repeatedly trying to get the books banned from her local school library because they promoted witchcraft and satanism. This lady also said she hadn't read the books because they were "too long"
And now I was old enough to be sad for her. She still to this day has no idea why she is fighting so hard to ban these books. She's taking the word of others who are in the same situation as her.
And then, finally, I read the final book in the series, the one I'd been waiting 10 years for and the final chapters absolutely stunned me with all the resonations of the gospel.
Of course J.K. Rowling knew she was portraying Harry as a Jesus figure. She is Christian, she has said so many times.
Yes, the story has magic and witches and spells. But thats not at all what the story is about, and children are smart enough to realise that. Thats why for millenia children have been taught lessons through fairy tales. They know that the magic isn't real, but it doesn't matter because it's a good story and the good guy wins and the girl marries the prince.
That's my story. Sorry it's so long.
#2 Crow
on October 11, 2007 at 8:33 a.m.(Houston, TX | Unverified Name)
Good for you for having the wits to read Harry Potter for yourself in order to know what the story really is about.
Might I suggest that you apply the same wisdom and strength to do the same with the "witch groups" before you go painting us all as cults and depressives?
A good place to start would be www.religioustolerance.org.
#3 Wen
on October 11, 2007 at 9:11 a.m.(Santa Barbara, CA | Unverified Name)
Wow, this author actually seemed to be open minded and objective until she started spouting ridiculous propaganda. She speaks of “witchcraft†as being synonymous with some sort of brainwashing cult. She states that “those trying to get out of witchcraft often show distinctive problemsâ€. How so? She makes a vague reference to churches being cursed by “witchcraft cults†via twisted nails??? It would appear that Ms. Flint is not entirely free of the Fundy programming that she received at high school. It may be the case that those trying to get out of “Christian cults†often show distinctive problems, such as an utter lack of objectivity.
#4 Wen
on October 11, 2007 at 9:11 a.m.(Santa Barbara, CA | Unverified Name)
Wow, this author actually seemed to be open minded and objective until she started spouting ridiculous propaganda. She speaks of “witchcraft†as being synonymous with some sort of brainwashing cult. She states that “those trying to get out of witchcraft often show distinctive problemsâ€. How so? She makes a vague reference to churches being cursed by “witchcraft cults†via twisted nails??? It would appear that Ms. Flint is not entirely free of the Fundy programming that she received at high school. It may be the case that those trying to get out of “Christian cults†often show distinctive problems, such as an utter lack of objectivity.
#5 Ben
on October 11, 2007 at 12:02 p.m.(Elizabethtown, IL | Unverified Name)
My school acts the same way! but i read harry potter all the same. i would do this as a current event for my class, but i am afraid my teacher might get angry and tyhen we'd all argue about wether it is christian or not.
My pastor reads harry potter tooo...
#6 Rhiannyn
on October 11, 2007 at 1:10 p.m.(Salisbury, MD | Unverified Name)
Hmm, I guess you could call me a witch, but more simply a Pagan, and I don't have a "higher rate of depression." I'm not a moody, broody person, and though I do most often dress in black (because it's slimming), I'm not what you would call Goth either. I'm actually a fairly successful manager at a well-known national retail store.
It's great that you were able to get past your squeamishness and actually read the Harry Potter series, but try actually going out and meeting some real Pagans before making broad, sweeping assumptions or taking someone else's word for it as well. I think you'll find that as a whole, we're a generally happy, well-adjusted bunch.
#7 Susan
on October 11, 2007 at 3:32 p.m.(Riverdale, IL | Unverified Name)
Good for you, very openminded. Although, I think you are mixing witchcraft (the craft, or Wiccan) with Satanism and any kind of cult, or religious cult. Some cults are Christian, and some believe in aliens, there all kinds of cults. Real witches don't do animal sacrifices or negative magic of any kind; they believe that what you do on to others comes back to you 3 times.
#8 Thalionariel
on October 12, 2007 at 1:12 p.m.(None, None | Unverified Name)
Great article when it comes to the common sense that Potter is no more than a great series.
Now take the next step and learn about the myriad of religions out there, expecially the witchy ones, since you are parroting inaccurate venom about Witches.
www.religioustolerance.org great site for learning about religious beliefs.
#9 John West
on October 13, 2007 at 1:17 p.m.(Milan, IN | Unverified Name)
I, like most of the people who have commented, wish you would take the time to meet some real Pagans. The fact is that the early church wanted to paint Witches in a negative light and unfortunately those negative stereotypes still remain. There is a good chance that everyone has a Witch in their life, it could be your neighbor or a co-worker but we are everywhere. Sadly we often have to keep our faith a secret to avoid persecution. The point is you all probably know a Witch and think nothing odd of them, whats even more sad is that your opinion of them would most likely change if you found out about their faith
#10 zahary
on November 2, 2007 at 8:50 a.m.(Big Spring, TX | Unverified Name)
you rock
#11 zachary
on November 2, 2007 at 8:51 a.m.(Big Spring, TX | Unverified Name)
you rock
Post a comment