The Daily of the University of Washington

Coverage of Oaxaca lacking


Under the "News" tab in MyUW on 11/29/06 there were links to articles describing the UW's decision to withdraw students from its language program in Oaxaca, Mexico due to "violent protests." Unfortunately both of these articles fundamentally mischaracterized the unfolding situation.

While the UW did not author these examples of poor journalism, it is a disservice to members of the UW community to offer these misleading articles as the only explanation.

According to Luis Hernández Navarro of the La Jornada (11/28/06), federal police forces "throw tear gas, violently beat people, arrest without warrants, invade houses without authorization, destroy property, occupy hospitals and clinics, interfere with the free movement of citizens and sexually violate women."

"It was they who began the aggression. And they did it brutality and with rancor. The repression was savage: three deaths, more than 100 injured, 221 detained."

Detainees, by the way, have been systematically tortured and denied access to lawyers. Sound familiar? Given that Mexico's leaders steadfastly claim their fidelity to democracy and the Governor of Oaxaca campaigned as a "man of unity," we in American should pay close attention to the hard lessons of Oaxaca and demand accurate coverage from the UW.

For further information I recommend www.narconews.com.

Josh Strange

Graduate student, aquatic and fishery sciences


2 Comments

#1 Elizabeth Russell
(Vancouver, WA | Unverified Name)

on December 1, 2006 at 3:41 p.m.
Report this comment

I am one of the students who was pulled from the study abroad program in Oaxaca and evacuated to Puebla on Tuesday. I have been reading the updates about Oaxaca on narconews.com, and as a person who has been in Oaxaca City for the last two months, I can say that that news site does not give an accurate portrayal of the events happening there either. They are very biased in favor of the APPO and only write about the bad things that happen to them, never about the atrocities that the APPO are committing every day. What people need to realize is that all of the media coverage about Oaxaca (or anything for that matter) is biased in one way or another and never tells the whole story. The APPO are not innocent, and the same goes for the PFP.

#2 Elizabeth Russell
(Vancouver, WA | Unverified Name)

on December 1, 2006 at 3:54 p.m.
Report this comment

To add to my last comment, I have read the story that the quotes are from in this letter to the editor and I found one blatant, unbelieveable lie in it which reads, "The demonstrations of this past Saturday were absolutely peaceful." I was standing on my rooftop outside of my room watching buildings burn down that the APPO had set ablaze such as the local theater and the building that housed the Secretary of Tourism office. They tore through the town and broke hundreds of windows and besides those two buildings burned many more. They provoke the police daily by throwing rocks and threatening them, and while this is no excuse for the violence that happened against the people, the police reacted violently in response to their violence. I don't know where people should get their news, but the whole story is never there on narco.


Post a comment

Name:


(None, None | Unverified Name)
Login to verify your name

Email:


Required, but not shown.

Comment: